phone mail2 facebook twitter play whatsapp
FILM REVIEW: Silence

FILM REVIEW: Silence

29 December 2016 | Edd Elliott

The release of Wolf Of Wall Street smashed a cocaine-white Lamborghini through the notion that it would be a peaceful slide into retirement for cinema legend Martin Scorsese. The very idea that the now 75 year-old director was in the room for the infamous plane orgy scene (although let’s be fair, what part of Wolf Of Wall Street wasn’t infamous) blows the mind. His latest film Silence is a change of tune – don’t expect peace-and-quiet, however.

The film travels to 17th century Japan, a kingdom shut off from the rest of the world where Christians are executed in state-endorsed displays of torture. Liam Neeson’s Jesuit priest Ferreira has renounced his faith, or so the rumours report. His two young disciples Rodrigues (Andrew Garfield) and Garrpe (Adam Driver) decide to venture forth and unearth the truth. Arriving at the island, the pair discover their quest is more gruelling than they could have ever imagined. The villagers who support them are persecuted, and the canny local Inquisitor is constantly looking for ways to expose Christianity’s hypocrisy. As the missionaries delve deeper and deeper into the foreign culture their difficulties mount, testing their religious reserve to the limit.
 

Photo Credit: Kerry Brown

Silence is Scorsese’s first filmic venture east, and the movie swirls with influences from Japanese cinema. A constant dialectic bounces back and forth between the amplified movement of Akira Kurosawa and the stillness and poise of Ozu. The film opens with an immense play of sounds. The soft rustle of bugs and birds swells into a cacophony, pounding into and through the audience, louder and louder. And then, silence – the eponymous Silence, as the title card appears.
 
It’s very much the model of the film. The trials of Rodrigues and Garrpe begin as the mild inconveniences. The priests must spend their days shut in a mountain hut, warned to stay hidden lest a passerby betray their location. They gall and gnaw at their tedious confinement, exasperated at being forestalled from seeking Ferreira. Venturing out in the open, however, their ordeals multiply rapidly. Having embarked off on his own, Rodrigues finds himself captured and tortured. The torment, however, is moral, not physical, as the Inquisitor and his mischievous gang force the preacher to watch as his flock are crucified, burnt, drowned, beheaded and exposed to the dreaded pit. “The tree of Christianity will not grow in Japan,” the Inquisitor demands. Rodrigues must renounce his faith to save those around him, a burden that mounts into an unbearable cross to bear.


 
For all its clamour and clang, however, Silence is an oddly austere film. Scorsese refrains from the usual Hollywood narrative dramatics. Although the priests’ merciless persecutors are cruel, they are never devils: their own fears as a culture invaded by foreign dogmas are always on show. Although the persecutions intensify, they are never elevated beyond the gruelling tests they are. There are no fireworks, no plot twists.
 
This thuddingly sombre pilgrimage is both the film’s greatest virtue and its greatest vice. On the one hand, the piety of endurance could not be more exalted. Garfield’s Rodrigues suffers more and more and more, and his righteous stamina under countless spiritual bludgeonings is Silence’s crowning affirmation. Yet, conversely, the homogeneity of the punishment upon punishment upon punishment makes the padre’s story decidedly flat (something one can very rarely say of Scorsese’s work). With no gloss or thrills, there is so little to hang on to outside martyrly pain and suffering. The film quickly becomes an exercise in stamina for the audience, as well as the protagonists, and many are likely to feel exhausted by two and a half hours of unremitting toil.

A tale of devout missionaries, Silence is, ironically, unlikely to convert the unconverted. Its unswerving discipline should be lauded, by Catholics and non-Catholics alike. However, most, one suspects, would much prefer Wolf of Wall Street’s spiralling revelry to this tumult of reverence.
 
**** - 4 stars

Tell us what you think

You may also like

Regional Theatre Summer Round-Up

Regional Theatre Summer Round-Up

There’s a whole heap of interesting underground theatre in the UK over the next couple of months. It’s always worth taking a trip to your local…

Win a Family Ticket to The Tiger Who Came to Tea!

Orchard Theatre - Win a Family Ticket to The Tiger Who Came to Tea!

Based on the classic children's book by Judith Kerr, a trip to this Olivier-nominated play is a treat for the whole family.

Weyfest in Surrey

Weyfest in Surrey

This relaxed rural festival takes place in August and features Jools Holland, Buzzcocks and a very beautiful camp site.

‘Ultimately Music Does Still Have that Magical Hold on Us’: An Interview with the Flaming Lips

‘Ultimately Music Does Still Have that Magical Hold on Us’: An Interview with the Flaming Lips

He’s the eccentric front man of Oklahoma alt-rock band the Flaming Lips with an impressive back catalogue of 17 studio albums, countless tours and collaborations with…

A Guide to Oxford’s Cocktail Bars

A Guide to Oxford’s Cocktail Bars

With the weather warming up the only thing anyone wants to do is sit outside with a chilled glass in hand. Lucky for us that…

Win a Fabulous Day Out at the Blenheim Palace Summer Jousting Tournament!

Blenheim Palace - Win a Fabulous Day Out at the Blenheim Palace Summer Jousting Tournament!

Join the formidable Knights of Arkley on the South Lawn of Blenheim Palace in Oxford in our special offer to win a day trip to...

‘Raphael: The Drawings’ at the Ashmolean Museum in Oxford

‘Raphael: The Drawings’ at the Ashmolean Museum in Oxford

Raphael is the definitive Italian Renaissance artist. Born Raffaello Sanzio in fifteenth-century Urbino, Italy, he emerged as a child prodigy and was declared a ‘master’ of…

Louise Reay: ‘Hard Mode’ at the Brighton Fringe

Louise Reay: ‘Hard Mode’ at the Brighton Fringe

Award-winning comedian and journalist Louise Reay talks censorship and imagines living in an authoritarian regime.

Win a Two-Course Roast for Two Plus a Jazz Performance!

Wycombe Swan - Win a Two-Course Roast for Two Plus a Jazz Performance!

Win a two-course Sunday Roast for two people complete with an essential selection of jazz and swing at the Wycombe Swan.

Win a Membership and Bird-Friendly Bundle!

SongBird Survival - Win a Membership and Bird-Friendly Bundle!

Help SongBird Survival save the dawn chorus for tomorrow.

Most popular

Win four tickets to a Dustin Hoffman screening - plus cocktails!

BFI Southbank - Win four tickets to a Dustin Hoffman screening - plus cocktails!

Celebrate the works of legendary actor Dustin Hoffman at London's BFI Cinema this summer!
Win a Family Ticket to The Tiger Who Came to Tea!

Orchard Theatre - Win a Family Ticket to The Tiger Who Came to Tea!

Based on the classic children's book by Judith Kerr, a trip to this Olivier-nominated play is a treat for the whole family.
Oxford’s Hidden Gems: Best Places to Eat

Oxford’s Hidden Gems: Best Places to Eat

In the second instalment of our monthly Oxford's Hidden Gems series, we take you on a tour of the best culinary corners of the city.
Win a Two-Course Roast for Two Plus a Jazz Performance!

Wycombe Swan - Win a Two-Course Roast for Two Plus a Jazz Performance!

Win a two-course Sunday Roast for two people complete with an essential selection of jazz and swing at the Wycombe Swan.
‘Ultimately Music Does Still Have that Magical Hold on Us’: An Interview with the Flaming Lips

‘Ultimately Music Does Still Have that Magical Hold on Us’: An Interview with the Flaming Lips

Explore the whimsical world of alt-rocker and Flaming Lips front man Wayne Coyne ahead of the band's show at the Brighton Dome.
A Guide to the Bristol Refugee Festival 2017

A Guide to the Bristol Refugee Festival 2017

This programme features film, live music, cycle rides and an Eid feast in a month-long celebration of Bristol's refugees.
Top 5: Picnic Spots in Cambridge

Top 5: Picnic Spots in Cambridge

Make the most of the hot weather this June with our pick of the perfect picnic spots in Cambridge.
Manchester on a Budget

Manchester on a Budget

Take a day trip to the city of football, Oasis, and birthplace of the modern computer without upsetting your bank balance.
‘I Could Have Done Science, But Instead I Became a Clown’: An Interview with Dara Ó Briain

‘I Could Have Done Science, But Instead I Became a Clown’: An Interview with Dara Ó Briain

One of the nation's favourite stand-ups chats to us about bamboozling the critics and his alternative life as a scientist.
Win a Fabulous Day Out at the Blenheim Palace Summer Jousting Tournament!

Blenheim Palace - Win a Fabulous Day Out at the Blenheim Palace Summer Jousting Tournament!

Here's your chance to win the perfect family day out at Blenheim Palace's thrilling Summer Jousting Tournament.

Your inbox deserves a little culture!